Attempts to compare and contrast kants ethics with kierkegaards. Divine commands and moral obligations can be taken as skillfully as picked to act. The problem of preferential love in kierkegaards works of love. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on youtube. I have been reading some of his books as they were written, in danish, and i can imagine that translators. Charles stephen evans born 1948 is an american philosopher. Hume, david 1972 enquiries concerning the human understanding and concerning the principles of morals, oxford university press.
Only this kind of love is capable of founding genuine ethical relations. The aesthetic, ethical, and religious forms of life. The account understands the relation humans have with a loving god as making possible the greatest human good, and as creating those unique obligations we designate as moral. Apr 02, 2021 john lippitt, editor john lippitt is professor of ethics and philosophy of religion at the university of hertfordshire. Kierkegaards central passion kierkegaard wrote industriously and rapidly, and under a vari ety of pennames, presenting various esthetic, ethical, and reli gious viewpoints on life.
Objectivity is the name for occupying oneself with what is out there in such a way as to exempt oneself from. Kierkegaards view of the relation between philosophy and ethics with the views of a thinker, who also considers them to be connected, but who use this connection to reach a very different conclusion, namely ludwig wittgenstein. Kierkegaard and evans on the problem of abraham manis. Jan 21, 2010 in sum, the question is no longer whether the ethics in fear and trembling is kierkegaard s ethics, or whether it is superseded in works of love.
Pdf kierkegaard and ethics aruthuckal varughese john. A socratic and christian care for the self in ethics, love, and faith in kierkegaard. Shiba, ebook pdf kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral obligations contains important information and a detailed explanation about ebook pdf kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral obligations, its contents of the package, names of things and what they do, setup, and operation. Jamie ferreira, the problematic agapeistic idealagain, in ethics, love, and faith in kierkegaard, ed. The role of love in the thought of kant and kierkegaard. Stephen evans explains and defends kierkegaards account of moral obligations as rooted in gods commands, the fundamental command. Self love and neighbor love in kierkegaards ethics abstract. Kierkegaard and the problem of selflove cambridge core. You may find ebook pdf kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral obligations document other than just manuals as we also make available many user guides, specifications documents, promotional details, setup documents and more. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Suffering and discourse ethics in kierkegaards religious stage. Divine commands and moral obligations 9780199206049. Works of love christian ethics and the maieutic ideal, trans. Stephen evans, 9780199206049, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
The divine relationship ethics of kierkegaards lovesleuth in. Pdf kierkegaard, repetition and ethical constancy researchgate. B is a second immediacy in relation to god, one spring ing from a. Kierkegaard on authentic selfhood and our need for others. Our site has the following ebook pdf kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral obligations available for free pdf download. He takes this to imply that self love and neighbor love should be roughly symmetrical, similar in kind as well.
Kierkegaards claims, in what follows i set the vision of works of love s ethics against the intertextual backdrop of kierkegaards thought on the individuals relatedness to god, and the nature of the love which god mandates towards others. As such, he thinks self love and neighbor love should be symmetrical, similar in kind as well as degree. Second, he is concerned with the manifestations of love. In each there is an ethical call to love in action. Kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral. Arnold come worries, are kierkegaards anthropology and theology really inseparable. Despite traditionally being characterised as a melancholy thinker with a propensity to dwell on existential anxiety, sin and despair, scholarly interest in the place of love in soren kierkegaards. Loss of the world in kierkegaards ethics, in kierkegaard. On selfhood, love, and politics opus university of. These three famous lifeviews are the aesthetic, the ethical, and the religious, represented in eitheror.
A compelling account of kierkegaards ethical views, seeing him against the backdrop. How this nothing functions underlies what kierkegaard urges in works of love and how zen compassion moves us to action. What tarquinius superbus spoke in his garden with the poppies was understood by his son, but not by the messenger. This kierkegaardian ethic, found principally in works of love, has advantages over its contemporary secular rivals, such as evolutionary naturalism, social contract theories, and moral relativism. Soren kierkegaard was the first existentialist philosopher, sharp and clear, ironic and down to earth at the same time. Dec 02, 2020 i conclude by showing that kierkegaard s failure to differentiate between the contents of different faithbased actions leads his faithbased religious ethic to fall into an ethical antinomy. Soren kierkegaard three dimensions of the religious life. Dec 31, 20 here is a great article by the philosopher jeff mason, in which he explains kierkegaards different forms of life.
First, love is indescribable, since god is love and god is unfathomable. The problem of preferential love in kierkegaard s works of love. Soren kierkegaard stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The work will be of interest not only to those interested in kierkegaard, but also to those interested in the relation between ethics and religion, especially questions about whether morality can or must have a. You may find ebook pdf kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and moral obligations document other than just manuals as we also make available many user guides, specifications documents, promotional details. His publications include humour and irony in kierkegaard s thought palgrave, 2000. Jan 09, 2020 a collection of books and writings by soren kierkegaard. The linchpin of both these strands of thought is the figure of jesus christ. At the heart of christian ethics is the biblical commandment to love god and to love ones neighbor as oneself.
The hidden debt, ronald green has shown how kants analysis of the existence of evil in religion within the bounds of reason alone influenced kierkegaard s thought, an influence that he thinks kierkegaard tried to hide. Stephen evans explains and defends kierkegaard s account of moral obligations as rooted in gods commands, the fundamental command being you shall love your neighbour as yourself. The divine relationship ethics of kierkegaards lovesleuth. A critical outline of kierkegaard s concept of love in the works of m. Gods commands should be obeyed, not because of fear of divine punishment, but out. The fundamental distinction is now between objectivity and subjectivity, with two examples of each. The philosophies of love and despair in kierkegaards early. Stephen evans in kierkegaard s ethic of love, i argue that kierkegaard regards this scenario as never actually resulting in a fully responsible agents performance of some horrendous action on account of her non. His writings display such a wide range of genre and style, and his thoug ht covers such a variety of sub.
Soren kierkegaard soren kierkegaard three dimensions of the religious life. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading kierkegaard s ethic of love. This commentary on soren kierkegaard s works of love 1847, a series of 15 deliberations on the love commandment to love ones neighbor as oneself, argues that works of love provides resources for understanding our ethical responsibility for others in ways that respect concrete distinctiveness and equality, partiality and impartiality, as well as the relation between self. Kierkegaard brought this potent mixture of discourses to bear as social. In this article, i argue that in works of love soren kierkegaard stays true to his lutheran roots in detailing an ethic of neighbor love that draws deeply on and unfolds the implications of the inseparable realities of justi. Since neither of these realities are explicit in works of love, the. Paul muller who writes that works helps to distinguish kierkegaards position from that of the pseudonyms, but it also shows some continuity with them, kierkegaards works of love christian ethics and the maieutic ideal, trans. One may only enter into an ethical way of life once one understands that an aesthetic life leads to angst and eventually despair. Christian love, on the other hand, is oriented toward the eternal. Kierkegaard presents a form of divine command theory of moral obligation similar to accounts developed by robert adams and philip quinn.
In 1847 kierkegaard wrote works of love, a piece on love in its various forms. Adorno, on kierkegaards doctrine of love philpapers. Soren kierkegaard is useful to us because of the intensity of his despair at the compromises and cruelties of daily life. Many have not been able to fully appreciate kierkegaards ethical stance because he has. He views works of love as seminal in the corpus of kierkegaard s authorship.
Additionally, this form of divine command theory resists the fundamental objections often posed against a religiously grounded ethic. Second, he is concerned with the manifestations of love in the christian life. Cambridge university press, 2009 kierkegaard on faith and the self. Kierkegaard and the 3 stages of a full and happy life by. Translated and published in portugese by editora vida, 2003. Selflove and neighbor love in kierkegaards ethics antony a.
Kierkegaard emphasizes the works of love for at least two reasons. Sharon krishek 2008 journal of religious ethics 36 4. The ethical life is based on moral codes, the infinite, and the eternal. Oxford university press, 2004 pocket dictionary of philosophy of religion and apologetics downers grove, illinois. Kierkegaards self and heideggers dasein analysis is to demonstrate that heidegger radicalises beyond kierkegaards self with his notion of dasein, whose mode of being is profoundly open and rightly undetermined as that which makes its own being an issue for itself. Jamie ferreira, the problematic agapeistic idealagain, in ethics, love, and faith in kierkegaard. Iii 2009 forgiveness in kierkegaards ethic of neighbor love, unpublished ph. Kierkegaard s writings are interspersed with remarkable stories of love, commonly understood as a literary device that illustrates the problematic nature of aesthetic and ethical forms of life, and the contrasting desirability of the life of faith. A collection of books and writings by soren kierkegaard.
Pdf selflove and neighborlove in kierkegaards ethics. He is university professor of philosophy and humanities at baylor university evans was born on may 26, 1948, in atlanta, georgia. Mar 31, 2021 john lippitt john lippitt is professor of ethics and philosophy of religion at the university of hertfordshire. Larrabee kierkegaard zen depaul university, chicago. Eitheror and fear and trembling kierkegaards ethic often has been the subject of vehement criticism, but what has been labeled kierkegaards. Since neither of these realities are explicit in works of love, the first part.
The simple scheme of the three stages becomes more complex in concluding unscientific postscript. On the one hand, he concurs with the biblical injunction. Divine commands and moral obligations kindle edition by evans, c. Kierkegaard s resistance to creating an allembracing. Divine commands and moral obligations kierkegaard presents a form of divine command theory of moral obligation similar to accounts developed by robert. The religious is the fulfillment, but difficult fulfillmentto rest joyful in the paradox.
This book took five years to write and forms his basis of divine command theory of ethics. The work will be of interest not only to those interested in kierkegaard, but also to those interested in the relation between ethics and religion, especially. Cambridge core nineteenthcentury philosophy kierkegaard. Despite traditionally being characterised as a melancholy thinker with a propensity to dwell on existential anxiety, sin and despair, scholarly interest in the place. All three forms of life are attempts to escape the universal condition of despair, according to kierkegaard. Across these themes, the aim is to lend voice to the unruly energy of the unsayable and, in doing so, let kierkegaard s theological, spiritual, and philosophical provocation remain a living one for us today. Kierkegaard confessed more than once that stages on lifes way is a very difficult work. On the one hand, he endorses the biblical command to love our neighbors as ourselves. The book examines kierkegaard s apophaticism with reference to five themes.
812 132 1079 371 1307 824 1189 852 193 1319 494 1381 521 253 351 661 900 78 9 173 1051 1399 139 5 1426 488 886 883 628 1464 639 948 195 531 874 547 862 1131 1006